Hunter analysed the 31 million emails its users sent in 2025 and found an average open rate of 30% (Hunter, 2026). SmartReach.io, with 40 million+ emails sent from January to June 2026, puts the open rate at about 28% and explicitly calls it inflated by Apple Mail Privacy Protection and security scanners (SmartReach.io, 2026).
Why opens are unreliable: in September 2026, Apple (including opens via Mail Privacy Protection) accounted for 76.56% of more than 1.5 billion opens tracked by Litmus. Gmail had 16.10% and Outlook 3.48% (Litmus, 2026). Benchmarks for open rates are therefore hard to compare between tools and years.
Open tracking can cost you replies
In Hunter’s data, sequences with open tracking switched on had a reply rate of 4.4%, against 7.4% without tracking: 68% higher (Hunter, 2026). A tracking pixel adds little reliable information and can hurt the metric that matters.
Open rates by subject line
| Subject line | Open rate | Reply rate |
|---|---|---|
| Two custom attributes (e.g. name + company) | 40.2% | – |
| One custom attribute | 35.4% | – |
| Subject lines other than “Quick question” | 32.9% | 2.9% |
| “Quick question” | 28.7% | 2.5% |
Sources: Hunter, 2026, SmartReach.io, 2026, Litmus, 2026